μεταcole

“Blogging, Podcasting, or Youtube? Choosing the right medium” – Podcamp Singapore

Posted in all posts, events, internet by coleman yee on November 1, 2008

Podcamp Singapore turned out to be quite fun, with some interesting conversations that I hope to blog about soon.

This post is about my thoughts as one of the speakers.

My session

I titled my session “Blogging, Podcasting, or Youtube? Choosing the right medium”.

A more accurate title would have been “Text, audio, or video? Issues to consider in choosing the online medium”, but I would have gotten only half the audience.

I chose this topic because I’ve seen too many people and organizations create a podcast or a video blog without understanding the strengths and weaknesses of the medium.

They may have started a podcast simply because it’s the cool thing to do, not realizing that there are a lot more subtleties involved in creating a good podcast.

It was these subtleties that I wanted to explore during the session.

The format

I was actually a facilitator rather than a speaker. I called the format a “virtual wiki” (a wiki is online, so a virtual wiki is offline) – where the audience gave their input and ideas while I tried to distill their thoughts onto the virtual wiki page (the whiteboard).

The content was audience-constructed, with virtually no contributions from me (although I did lead the discussions in certain directions).

This meant that there were some points that I had in mind that weren’t raised by the audience, but it didn’t matter. What I wanted more was to guide the audience through this thinking process and experience, and I think I was successful in that.

The actual content

Since the actual content wasn’t from me, I don’t have a copy of it. Thankfully some of the audience were busy blogging during the session. Derrick Kwa covered the session live while Claudia covered my session as well as the other sessions live. Unfortunately they didn’t contribute to the discussion because they were too busy blogging about it.

(Update: Shalabh Pandey blogged about the content as well.)

There was also some plurking around in the background by Brian and some others, with one of them wanting to throw cheesecake at me. Thankfully I wrote on the whiteboard before I starting, “NO CAKE-THROWING”.

Feedback

Knowing that people tend to be reluctant about giving negative feedback, I asked a lot of people “what are the 3 things you liked and 3 things you disliked about the session” (later reduced to 2 things because most people had a hard time coming up with 3).

Most enjoyed the discussions. With very smart and knowledgeable individuals in the room, you can never go wrong letting go and giving them the freedom to converse.

However, not everyone was used to the lack of structure. During the discussions, there wasn’t always a clear direction, and the discussions often digressed. It was disorienting for some.

Furthermore, when the session ended, there were more questions than answers. Not everyone liked the lack of closure.

What I would have done differently

First, I would have framed the issue more clearly. I had some assumptions which weren’t shared by everyone, so the scope of the discussion went too broad at some points.

I should have also prepared the audience better for the lack of structure and closure.

Many of us are too used to the comfort of structure and guidance and we want to be given the correct or model answer. While I wanted to raise questions more than to give answers, it would have worked better if the audience was expecting it.

Finally

Despite all the flaws, I’m generally satisfied with how it turned out. I hope others will also be encouraged to try out a similarly participatory or even constructivistic session in the future.

Advertisements

12 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Derrick Kwa said, on November 1, 2008 at 10:31 pm

    Hey! I did contribute to the discussion! =P. Haha. Not that much, but yeah.

    But anyway, thanks for holding the session, it was definitely interesting.

  2. claudia said, on November 1, 2008 at 10:41 pm

    perhaps we can try letting the audience burnt their fingers to learn that fire is hot in future sessions at smb|sg

  3. coleman yee said, on November 1, 2008 at 11:00 pm

    @Derrick: I totally forgot! But now that you mention, I vaguely remember now 🙂

    @claudia: hats off to you and Derrick for liveblogging!

  4. Daisy said, on November 2, 2008 at 12:02 pm

    text is “one medium fits all”, audio is “story-telling” without the need to see/watch it, and lastly video, “a stage for performance” an entertaining and precise one.

  5. oldskoolmark said, on November 2, 2008 at 1:11 pm

    Nice meeting you at PodCamp!! 🙂

  6. […] us share with you some of the following entries that have been done regarding our event! Here are some of Coleman’s thoughts on being a speaker. Derrick also covered some of the speaker […]

  7. Vincent said, on November 3, 2008 at 8:29 pm

    So what were your original thoughts? There’s no one here to deviate you this time…

  8. coleman yee said, on November 3, 2008 at 11:20 pm

    @Vincent: not so much my original thoughts but thoughts I had that weren’t mentioned. These include download/bandwidth differences and implications; the typical access environments (on a pc vs mobile device); the skills needed for quality content (e.g. rhythm, cadence, structure); and other bits and pieces (e.g. music, visual grammar, etc.). Not entirely organized as you can see.

    Anyway, thanks for contributing during the session.

  9. […] Podcamp Singapore, the topic came up in both the sessions I attended. Coleman talked about choosing the right medium – text, audio or video. As you can imagine, one of the main factors discussed was about audience […]

  10. welovefoodcoma said, on November 5, 2008 at 1:26 am

    Hi Coleman! This is yixuan here, thanks for the special mention of Podcamp and your session was really interactive and engaging; a really nice change from the morning sessions. 🙂

  11. geriberi said, on November 12, 2008 at 2:57 pm

    HELLO haha I couldnt really attend your session cuz i had a shift in the other room but anyways, heard your session was good! BTW i posted ur picture on my blog. HAHA

  12. […] presentation, teaching — Tags: powerpoint — coleman yee @ 11:04 pm In my last post “Blogging, Podcasting, or Youtube? Choosing the right medium” – Podcamp Singapore, I talked about my experience as a speaker at Podcamp […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: